CHAPEL HILL, N.C. (SELC) —The North Carolina Utilities Commission today issued final orders partially approving Duke Energy’s Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress rate increase requests, at a time when residential customers face an escalating cost of living crisis. The commission also signed off on an excessively high 9.8% return on equity that prioritizes shareholder profits and puts too many grid costs on the shoulders of residential customers.
The North Carolina Justice Center, North Carolina Housing Coalition, Southern Alliance for Clean Energy, and Vote Solar, represented by the Southern Environmental Law Center, voiced their overall disapproval of the orders but partially supported one aspect: the approval of a data center-specific tariff. Although a welcome development, the tariff only applies to a subset of large load customers. In addition, the commission’s rulings functionally defer resolution of whether data center customers on this tariff will pay their fair share of the grid upgrade and power plant costs that they trigger to a stakeholder process.
The groups intervened in the proceedings to oppose the Duke Energy Carolinas (DEC) and Duke Energy Progress (DEP) proposals to increase residential rates by approximately 18% and demonstrated that Duke can reduce energy bills by lowering its proposed return on equity and facilitating the investment in clean energy sources rather than polluting fossil fuels.
“The commission’s rulings unfortunately raise electricity rates for North Carolinians but keep them lower than Duke’s proposed rate hikes and chart a potential pathway to tamp down future rate hikes that stem from large customer power demand and ensure that the utility’s approved rates recover only reasonable utility system costs,” said Munashe Magarira, a Senior Attorney with the Southern Environmental Law Center. “More importantly, they represent a missed opportunity to more comprehensively address the cost-of-living crisis and advance the clean energy transition head on.”
Key takeaways from the orders:
- The commission approved a 9.8% return on equity for DEC and DEP, as opposed to the groups’ proposed a 9.1% return on equity that could have saved ratepayers as much as $280 million and given struggling customers some needed relief on their energy bills.
- The data center tariff does not include an optional clean transition tariff, which would help incentivize additional clean energy deployments for data center customers rather than increased pollution and help keep Duke Energy on track to meet its carbon pollution reduction requirements under state law.
- The commission’s orders approve a cost recovery framework that allocates a disproportionate share of grid costs to residential customers, further increasing their utility bills.
- Approve $20 million in shareholder funds to support low-income bill payment assistance and home energy efficiency upgrades, which will provide some relief to our state’s most vulnerable residents, but is fundamentally inadequate given the likely termination of the Customer Assistance Program.
The clean energy groups and advocates’ reactions are below:
“While we appreciate the commission taking action to assign certain system costs to data centers, it failed to take the step of ensuring that data centers can fund their own clean energy, thereby taking power generation cost risk completely off of other ratepayers,” said Eddy Moore, Decarbonization Director at the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy.
“Although lower than what Duke originally proposed, this decision sadly still locks in rate increases for all North Carolinians, while at the same time offering insufficient assistance for those already struggling most to pay their electric bills. We call on Duke Energy to request the NC Utilities Commission’s approval to extend the Customer Assistance Program and not let 87,000 customers’ bills jump $52 come January 1,” said Claire Williamson, Senior Energy Policy Advocate at the North Carolina Justice Center.
“The commission’s rulings lowering Duke’s rate increases are no doubt helpful. However, these reductions ultimately amount to a band-aid given the scale and reach of the ongoing cost of living crisis,” said Samuel Gunter, Executive Director of the North Carolina Housing Coalition.
“Solar and other clean energy resources remain the cheapest sources of power and the quickest to come online. Creating another opportunity to build additional renewables at scale through a clean transition tariff would go a long way to helping address the current cost of living crisis, while ensuring Duke Energy’s compliance with state carbon reduction laws,” said Jake Duncan, Senior Southeast Regulatory Director at Vote Solar.
Media contacts: Kathleen Sullivan, SELC, 919-945-7106, ksullivan@selc.org; Amy Rawe, SACE, 865-235-1448, amyr@cleanenergy.org.
###
About Southern Environmental Law Center
The Southern Environmental Law Center is one of the nation’s most powerful defenders of the environment, rooted in the South. With a long track record, SELC takes on the toughest environmental challenges in court, in government, and in our communities to protect our region’s air, water, climate, wildlife, lands, and people. Nonprofit and nonpartisan, the organization has a staff of 250, including more than 160 legal and policy experts and advocates, and is headquartered in Charlottesville, VA, with offices in Asheville, Atlanta, Birmingham, Chapel Hill, Charleston, Nashville, Richmond, and Washington, DC. Learn more at selc.org.
About the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy
Since 1985, the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy has worked to promote responsible and equitable energy choices to ensure clean, safe, and healthy communities throughout the Southeast. Learn more at cleanenergy.org.